ONLINE FIRST
published on October 24, 2018
Brian Dunkle, S.J.
https://doi.org/10.5840/augstudies2018102348
¡°Made Worthy of the Holy Spirit¡±
A Hymn of Ambrose in Augustine¡¯s Nature and Grace
Among the ¡°patristic¡± authorities that Augustine invokes near the end of his anti-Pelagian work De natura et gratia is a couplet from Ambrose¡¯s hymn, ¡°Iam Surgit Hora Tertia.¡± While these lines have been cited as evidence of the hymn¡¯s authenticity, few have examined their function and meaning in the context of the treatise. I argue that the lines illustrate Augustine¡¯s distinctive use of authorities in De natura et gratia and that this use is driven by two primary motives: first, Augustine wants to counter Pelagius¡¯s use and citation of authorities in Pelagius¡¯s work De natura; and, second, Augustine wants to advance his own views on the necessity of the grace of Christ. Turning to ¡°Iam Surgit,¡± I first show that Augustine seeks to counter a potential Pelagian ¡°abuse¡± of the hymn, and especially the way the Pelagians might exploit its reference to ¡°merit.¡± I then speculate that Augustine uses the hymn to offer implicit support for his own understanding of grace since, according to his reading, the source of forgiveness in Ambrose¡¯s hymn is the gratia Christi. Augustine thus shows not only that Ambrose¡¯s words are media, that is, equally supportive of both sides in the dispute, but also that they advance Augustine¡¯s developing views on the priority of the grace of Christ in the prayers of humanity.