Volume 32, Issue 4, October 2015
Igor Gasparov
Pages 432-438
https://doi.org/10.5840/faithphil201592145
Emergent Dualism and the Challenge of Vagueness
In two recent papers, Dean Zimmerman has argued that the vagueness of ordinary physical objects poses a challenge for ¡°garden variety¡± materialism (roughly, the view that the subject of conscious experiences is identical with the brain or the whole human organism), and that emergent substance dualism can deal more successfully with the problem of vagueness. In this paper I try to show that emergent dualism is vulnerable to the challenge of vagueness to the same extent as is ¡°garden variety¡± materialism.