ONLINE FIRST
published on May 12, 2023
Evan Dutmer
https://doi.org/10.5840/ipq2023510193
Imagination and the Genealogy of Morals in the Appendix to Spinoza¡¯s Ethics 1
The so-called ¡°analytical¡± appendix to the first part of Spinoza¡¯s Ethics has at times puzzled scholars. It notably breaks with the geometrical method adopted in most of the text, and includes an impassioned argument against teleology, popular morality, and, ultimately, the faculty of imagination. In this essay I seek to resolve this interpretive diffi?culty by side-by-side comparison with philosophical resources from one of Spinoza¡¯s main influences. In particular, I argue that analysis of the appendix to the first part of his Ethics is benefitted by comparison with certain Maimonidean arguments regarding the ¡°imagina?tion¡±¡ªthemselves part of a long tradition of debate on the powers of the imaginative faculty in ancient and medieval philosophy¡ªcontained in The Guide of the Perplexed. I introduce and trace this connection across both texts. This helps us to better appreciate both the ap?pendix and its place within the Ethics and Spinoza¡¯s sustained, complicated relationship with Medieval Judaism¡¯s greatest thinker.